Monday, 30 October 2006

Child labor---is this the RIGHT way???


I saw lots of blogs against child labor. Lots of opinions, lots…. Heard a lot…seen a lot..(not in y360!).  I know children who are working , personally….. in fact I grew up in a place, where there were a lot of poor people living in colonies, just on the back of my house, separated by a single wall. Every single day, till I was 15,  I saw, I heard their life. Their sorrows, their screams, and above all…. their hunger. And one among them (just a single one, among the hundreds!) was she. She was the mother of 5. Her husband was living in alcohol 24/7. She used to bring milk to our home. She had terrible Asthma, cos of the regular beating she got from her husband. Every nite, we heard her screams along with her children’s. Soon, she was down with illness, her 5 kids cried in hunger. And very soon the eldest of them, then she was my age (8), came to us. She was hungry…just simply hungry. We could give them, food for once.. for 5 kids… next day when they were hungry again, she came to us and begged my grandfather(achachan) to give her some job, so that she can feed 5 rumbling stomachs and pay for her mom’s medicines. She needed money…not food!!! Finally my grandfather asked her to bring cow dung (that was available at her home). He said that just cos of her heart-melting begging (I was the witness to her begging!). She came with cow dung and my granddad gave her Rs 2 for each basket she bought.(with 2 Rs we could buy 2 kilo of rice, then!) That day she earned 10 Rs. Next day too she came. But we didn’t want it anymore. But my achachan bought it and gave her money. Soon our home was filled with cow dung. Still my achachan didn’t ask her to stop just cos, he knew her family situation….


 


Soon she started working in other homes as maid(as that paid her more!).


Every single child who is working will have a similar story to tell. By abolishing child labor like this, does the govt solve their poverty??? Are they seeing their hunger stricken faces??? Do they hear their hungry screams????NO…NO…they just go and abolish child labor….without solving the core reason or root of the problem. By doing this , what are they thinking to achieve??? Why are they blind to the reasons which forced them to work???? Why don’t they go and take a look at their family?? And why, don’t they solve their hunger first and then abolish child labor, next??? Is their any law to feed hungry children???? Then why are they preventing their only way to satisfy their hunger???


 


Is this the right way to approach child labor???? By simply making law to prevent child labor, can they themselves be sure that those children are fed and protected???? NEVER…NEVER…this is another wrong way….an entirely wrong way… why we are all blind to the hunger behind those child labourers??? Why don’t we solve that first, rather than trying to prevent their only way to food????


 

15 comments:

  1. Well said Swathi:)
    This is wht im talking and writing for some time. Bringing law and baning child labor comes second. First me must provide them food shelter and education. It is proven that hunger leads to crime!

    A good example of this is how the Govt of Kerala banned begging in public places. They first setup nursing homes and setup a small police force to find beggars and help them to find their relatives or to transfer them to a nearby nursing home.Then they enforced the law. This was a success and..i havnt seen any beggars for last 4-5 months.

    I know the amount of beggars here is not comparable to millions of child labors. But as u said this is the way to adopt.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In my opinion, The Government Should introduce Forcible education system which can prevent child labour.

    We need to look at those families who are really dependent on their children because of their handicapness or some other valid reason. For those families Government should provide rehabilitation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Does it mean that if we abolish child labor, we should stop working for poverty alleviation as well?? Why can't we work for both side by side??

    ...and what about those children who don't want to but are forced to work?? Don't they deserve halp?? Should we let the children work because there is poverty in their homes or work towards removing poverty as well as letting them have a childhood??

    ReplyDelete
  4. shail--i never meant that....what i meant was that isnt there a chance that it may turn out like the "abloishment of alcohol"? the reason is for good, i agree... but simply abolishing things WITHOUT doing complete measures to eradicate the "reasons" behind it--will it really serve the cause???
    i just meant that....
    i know the intention is very good....but i am not sure the govt (or the society) has taken the complete responsibility of those kid's poverty.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A nice question....n well said...but I see soo many families in my neighbourhood(in India) where they send boys to school n gals to work...isnt tht partiality.There are soo many things behind child labour...n many questions which need solutions

    ReplyDelete
  6. That is precisely the point I made in response to Chris V`s blog on Child Poverty - it is a twin problem - hunger v. child labour - both problems have to be solved. I have put a link to the excellent UNICEF site on my blast. Anne

    ReplyDelete
  7. PS: I, too, was surprised at the lack of response to this subject on 360

    ReplyDelete
  8. I certainly think that banning CL will not solve it by itself... we have to feed those hungry mouths, provide them with homes, education... all in all take care of all those needs and more which their meager income took care of...
    On personal level if we sponsor a child each, we can accomplish a lot...
    And on a collective level force governments to have free education, food for children below a certain age...
    Hope we can make a difference...

    ReplyDelete
  9. you know swathi..... i too read a lot of blogs that spoke abt CL....
    when did we ever foll any law?..when we do..it creates a bit too much tension.....

    these children need ppl who can suport them.....financially.... if ppl like u an me can make a small diff in their life.... it is really good..... my team and i are walking ahead with the satisfaction of eduacating almost 60 children.... most of them girls.... and this is just a journey that needs to starts....

    thaks for this blog...
    seeee yaaa

    ReplyDelete
  10. Obviously I can't speak for how it is in other countries, but here in the US child labor laws doesn't necessarily mean a child can't work... The laws are there to protect the child so as not to encourage sweatshop-like conditions (which yes, there are still some here in the states... in fact I was just reading of an incident concerning Disney and a sweatshop he [the company] was running in Los Angeles, CA)...

    There are laws that prohibit children under the age of 16 from working in any hazardous type of situation (i.e. power-driven machines, roofing operations, driving motor vehicles, etc.)... Children under 16 are restricted from working during school hours and of course there are separate, or additional laws for those who work in the entertainment industry (movies, tv, music, etc)... So it's not so much to stop child labor, per se, just to protect...

    Also, here in the states, and I think there are certain agencies elsewhere in the world under different names, but they have welfare and food stamps and other agencies that help with food, rent, utilities cost as well as provide money for clothes, basic necessities and the like... but of course there are those who abuse the system making it so much harder for those who really do need these resources to obtain them because then they [the ones who are really in need] are the ones scrutinized when they do try to obtain these services...

    ReplyDelete
  11. issue representation is nice,
    but there is no suggetions to arradicate the issue

    ReplyDelete
  12. u said it well swathi chechy, certainly its not the way to the solution for hungry stomach.. once it stopped in such a way it demands other solution for stomach... crime,robbery, begging.. of course hungry is the crime.. it is the villain.. we need to punish hungry first..not to the hungry child...
    such rule is nothing but law dissolves its hunger...

    ReplyDelete
  13. Poverty,hunger,child labour & education...I think all go hand in hand.Sabiha & Ithee seem to have made some valuable suggestions above...

    ReplyDelete
  14. you said it all !

    ReplyDelete
  15. Your post drives the nail right into the wall. Totally agree glad to see so many people stand up for a good cause. I am adding your link to my page.
    I just hope this flame doesnt die out.

    ReplyDelete

Featured post

The diary of a working mommy....

Ok, this is about the woes of being a working mommy. Now before other mommies who work at home abuse me, I want to make myself clear that wh...